
In an alliance project, the establishment audit isn't about confirming that your numbers are true; that's what your external accountants are there for. What it does is figure out what they mean under the terms of the Project Alliance Agreement (PAA), the contract behind an alliance and similar to integrated project delivery (IPD), and no Canadian firm’s books were set up for that. The auditor tests key inputs, applies a consistent method to work out business-as-usual (BAU) markups for all proponents in accordance with the PAA, and produces a summary report to guide the team in fee negotiations. This article will help your firm prepare for this process so that you walk into the audit with a position, rather than just the auditor’s request list.
You have read the stacks of documentation provided by the project owner and the alliance auditor has sent their establishment audit guide and a list of requested documents. For the most part, the requests are as expected.
Upon further reading, however, you begin to realize that some of these requests may not be so straightforward. Your firm does not track non-billable hours with dedicated time codes. Software expenses are all booked into a single overhead account. Your employee benefits account includes a mix of benefit types allocated across employee classes. How will the auditors respond to this mess of data?
Alliance RFPs come in a variety of formats, particularly in Canada where this contracting method is still new and has yet to standardize. They do, however, have the establishment audit in common, because the model is open book. In an audit-first process, proponents undergo an audit to provide a baseline for the fee negotiations whereas in a bid-first process, the audit serves to validate the basis for the bid you submitted in the RFP.
It is crucial to understand what the audit is, and what it is not. Auditors are there to provide assurance to the owner that the claims being made about overhead and margins under the alliance's BAU principle are defensible. They may also be asked to comment on the sufficiency of each proponent's internal controls to mitigate the risk of errors or inappropriate charges to the project. The establishment audit also sets the standards for how the annual reconciliation of billed amounts will be conducted.
What the auditor does not do is re-litigate the accounting for each year; they rely primarily on financial statements prepared by your external accountants. A stricter external engagement - an audit versus a compilation - will plausibly reduce levels of scrutiny on your statements, but only to a point: compensation, timesheets, and subledger reconciliations will be tested regardless.
After reviewing your data and interviewing your financial leadership to understand the underlying structures and processes, the auditors will map your chart of accounts to the alliance's three-limb compensation structure. Limb 1 contains reimbursable direct costs and related burdens. Limb 2 is your fee, comprising corporate overheads and profits. Limb 3 is the Pain/Gain Share mechanism and is not part of the audit. The categorized accounts are reviewed and normalized, sometimes prorating them across limbs based on utilization rates or other factors. The result is the establishment audit report, shared with the project owners and all members of your team, meaning the constructor partner will see your results, and you will see theirs. The report forms the basis of discussions in the commercial alignment workshop, which in my experience is an opportunity to discuss unresolved PAA questions with the owners and advocate for changes that will yield a best-for-project outcome.
The financial structure of a typical alliance is as follows.
Billing amounts are based on direct labour and are marked up to include payroll burdens and other employment-related costs. Depending on the alliance, certain overheads such as design software may also be recoverable if they are viewed as being necessarily linked to the project's delivery. This is the labour component of Limb 1. Limb 2, the sum of your corporate overheads and profit, is usually applied as a markup on Limb 1 so that the resulting billings are calculated as DIRECT LABOUR × (1 + LIMB 1%) × (1 + LIMB 2%).
In my experience, the draft PAA will contain detailed schedules defining treatments for common expense items, so there isn't usually much to discuss around the mapping exercise, unless you are prepared to push back on the PAA. The real complexity, depending on how your accounts are structured, comes with the normalization of accounts. Utilization rates, an anomalous year, one-off expenses, non-operating items like income taxes or gain/loss on disposal of capital items, or an accounting change effective after the start of the audit period all warrant an adjustment. Crucially, the normalization principles employed by the auditor will be applied consistently across all participants to ensure a like-for-like comparison.
One useful example of how accounts can be normalized is health benefits. If your benefits provider has itemized billing per employee, the first step is to identify premiums for billable staff. If you have no itemized billing, then the auditor may prorate on the ratio of billable headcount to the firm's total. Having isolated the expense attributable to billable resources, the auditor may then further split that amount by the average utilization rate among that cohort and so arrive at the value of health benefits expense driven by direct labour. Everything else would remain in the Limb 2 bucket for inclusion in your fee.
A common question among firms entering an open-book engagement for the first time is who will be able to see what information. Though you are engaging with this client for an alliance project, you may also work with them on other jobs, and the concern is that knowing your overheads and margins would give them an unfair advantage on those.
While this is valid, what the owner ultimately sees is the summary report produced by the auditor, containing only high-level numbers that have been reworked to comply with the alliance definitions. They do not see account-level details or the normalizing adjustments made during the audit. The auditor, strictly bound by a code of professional ethics, is the only one who sees all the details.
Your relationship with the auditor is an important one and should be viewed as collaborative rather than adversarial. My experience of working with several different auditors across multiple projects has been that they are open to hearing alternative viewpoints on the treatment of various cost elements, and they can even make recommendations to the owners about amendments to the PAA that would more fairly reflect your BAU. You should also consider that a good working relationship is often a significant deciding factor in forming an alliance, and in my view, the auditor’s experience of working with your team will reach the owners.
What, then, is the best way to navigate this process? Below are five actions you should consider when preparing your firm for an upcoming establishment audit.
(1) As a first step, if PAA cost schedules are available, you should run a trial balance report on your accounts and distribute the balance of each to Limb 1 or 2. Be aware that anywhere you make a judgment call in favour of Limb 1, you simultaneously reduce your risk under pain share and your potential upside under gain share. Where an account's balance needs to be divided between the two, be sure to capture your rationale and the inputs from which the ratio was calculated. Set up your positions as though you were the auditor, and flag any assumptions made so they can be discussed.
(2) Confirm the policies governing the treatment of overtime for employees, non-productive time, cost rates, and whether the direct labour account contains any burden. Review whether these policies are consistently applied in practice, and whether there are any regular exceptions, as these are items the auditors are certain to ask about. Unpaid overtime billed as labour is of particular interest, as that may be viewed by the auditor as excess profit and consequently disallowed.
(3) Review your principals' compensation structure and how each component maps to the PAA. Alliances generally do not compensate for principals’ hours spent on Alliance Leadership Team (ALT) duties. If the Principal-in-Charge’s utilization rate falls below average, the fee becomes insufficient to cover the unbilled time because Limb 2 is calculated as a markup on billable labour.
(4) As a precaution, confirm that your subledgers, particularly those related to time and labour costs, tie out with your general ledger accounts. Many auditors take a sampling approach, and every difference they find can then lead to more samples. While I have not seen errors penalized, this adds to the burden on your team during the audit and may lead to the auditor raising concerns around financial controls in their report to the owner.
(5) Longer term, if your firm intends to pursue more alliance projects, it is worth considering a few changes to your bookkeeping practices. Chief among these is the tracking of all hours in timesheets, not only billable ones. It is also worth tracking each type of unpaid time with its own code and allocating overhead to projects wherever possible. These changes will reduce the complexity and effort required in future audits, as well as putting your firm in a better position to defend your interests before locking into a multi-year contract.
Alliances are comparatively new in Canada, and the market is still developing its norms. Auditors understand that your books were never kept with alliance contracting in mind, and they are willing to work with you to translate what you have into the alliance's own terms. They are a significant ally in ensuring not that you get the highest fees on the project, but rather that you get the fairest fees. Having sat through several such audits, my view is simple: know your books in alliance terms and you start the audit with a position, rather than just the auditor’s request.