
Alliance projects, a contracting structure similar to Integrated Project Delivery (IPD), take your usual billing multiplier and cut it into two components: recoverable direct costs, and corporate overhead plus profit. The numbers are then adapted to fit within the alliance's definitions, which is where a weak understanding of your cost structures could end up costing you. The open-book process contains a few subtle ways in which you could find yourself earning less than expected and left wondering what happened.
Your team worked diligently as the firm navigated the unfamiliar process of an Alliance RFP, and everyone celebrated when the contract was signed. Now, a year later, you're reading a management report telling you that the project is performing below the firm's norms, even though the Alliance itself is on budget. How could this be?
The auditors had meticulously reviewed your financials and communicated with your team that their aim was to produce a business-as-usual (BAU) equivalent fee. No significant amounts had been disallowed from overheads, and all accounts were duly classified and normalized. Your controller reviewed the analysis and signed off. Have you committed your firm to eight years of subpar results? Here are four ways I’ve seen money leak: your fee benchmark looks backward, the painshare mechanism might have been triggered, you underbid because someone misinterpreted your costs, hours may be going unrecorded.
In a P3 or other fixed fee contract, you provide a quote containing your direct costs, overhead expenses, profit, and contingencies. You take a labour estimate and apply your firm's billing multiplier. Most of the time, the results are consistent.
Alliances, however, are open-book and won't accept a black box approach to fees. They review your historical financial records and analyze your revenues and costs using a three-limb model.
Limb 1 is direct cost recovery, including payroll burdens. Limb 2 is what the alliance calls your Fee: the sum of Overhead and Profit, expressed as a percentage of Limb 1. This label can be a source of confusion because the Fee is net of the direct costs you recovered in Limb 1 and is not your total income.
Limb 3 is Painshare or Gainshare, and this is where the risk sharing occurs. Projects begin with the development of a Target Outturn Cost (TOC), the benchmark against which Limb 3 amounts are calculated. Cost overruns or underruns relative to the TOC will result in amounts payable or receivable so that all members of the alliance participate in budget variances. Limb 3 is not considered in the billing terms because by design it is intended to be zero, so this article won’t go into the details.
The audit identifies all expenses legitimately incurred in project delivery and applies them as burdens on direct labour (Limb 1) and then defines the Fee as a percentage of Limb 1, normalized to comply with the draft Project Alliance Agreement (PAA). As a principle, Alliances make decisions on a best-for-project basis; compensation sits firmly within that to ensure the desired outcomes.
The Canadian Alliance RFPs I’ve seen will typically run one of two ways: Audit-first or Bid-first. In the former, you work with the auditor while they normalize your data to produce a report that becomes the basis of fee negotiations in the Commercial Alignment workshop. In the latter, each entity calculates its own multipliers for submission as a binding bid in the RFP, with the audit subsequently validating the basis of each number.
While definitions can vary, your firm's standard Labour Multiplier is probably Net Revenue divided by Direct Labour. What's left is the money with which you fund operations and provide returns for your firm's owners. According to the 47th Deltek Clarity A&E report, firms in North America average 3.1.
In an alliance, though, items that might normally have been considered overhead become Limb 1, like your payroll burden. This brings down the multiplier because Limb 2 is based on fully burdened labour. Remember that the Fee in the alliance is not what you are used to thinking of as your fee. A firm with a total multiplier of 3.0 and a payroll burden of 25% would expect a Limb 2 markup of 140% on Limb 1. None of this considers separate markups for co-op students, or administrative fees billed on subconsultants or disbursements, all of which compound the complexity of creating a valid comparison.
So, if the multipliers themselves don’t cause underperformance, then what does? In this article, I’ve identified four common ways in which an alliance project can leak revenue or otherwise underperform.
(1) If you reviewed your firm's overhead and profit relative to direct labour for the last ten years, would they be flat? If so, then your firm is probably in a good position to perform well under an alliance model. Most firms, however, expect to see some changes in that time. Perhaps they have seen profits increase as their reputation developed, or maybe overheads have come down as they automated more administrative processes.
If you expect either or both of overhead and profit to increase into the future, you risk underbilling relative to actuals. In addition, participation in an alliance can add overhead via advance hiring & resulting bench time, new hire onboarding, and unbillable alliance leadership hours, all of which can skew your overheads in a way that was not accounted for.
(2) Another potential impact on your profitability is that all of Limb 2, not just your profit, is typically at risk under Limb 3. This doesn't affect all projects, but the TOC is usually set to give the project a 50% chance either way. If you do end up in painshare, at the extreme you risk having to give back all of your recovered overheads, resulting in a very real loss. What’s worse, the annual true-ups on Limb 1 affect the Actual Outturn Cost and risk adding to the painshare.
(3) In the case of a bid-first RFP process you calculate your fees in-house, likely without the benefit of the auditor's expertise. Alliance accounting is different from traditional projects, and your accounting team may not catch all the nuances and pitfalls involved in pricing. If the RFP prohibits fee revisions after submission, any errors later caught by the auditor could end up costing you. Errors in Limb 1 are less problematic because there is an annual reconciliation, so if you underbid you will still be made whole eventually. The same, however, cannot be said for underbidding on Limb 2 where there is no reconciliation and the RFP does not allow a correction.
(4) With your team under pressure to stay within the TOC, there's a real likelihood of time going unrecorded, creating ‘phantom hours’. While the PAA is generally clear that rework and other legitimate direct labour is billable to the project, staff have been known to 'take one for the team' on occasion. Any hours written off or otherwise not billed forfeit both the Limb 2 fee AND Limb 1 cost recovery, adding to the loss. If your firm consistently records all staff hours, then this is less of a problem… unless staff record hours under a different code. If, however, your firm only records direct hours, then an employee could easily allow some hours to disappear and implicitly become indirect time. The employee still gets their salary, the project budget gets a boost, and your firm quietly picks up the tab.
With these concerns in mind, here are 5 things you can do to prepare your firm for the commercial portion of your alliance bid.
(1) Confirm that all markups combine to your usual multiplier:
(1 + Limb 1%) x (1 + Limb 2%) = Net Multiplier
Gaps could come from a variety of sources. Direct labour in your ledger might carry some burden. Revenue from markups on subconsultants or disbursements can be difficult to properly model. Accounts may have been excluded from both Limbs 1 and 2 (check non-operating expenses and partner compensation). The math can get complicated fast, but do not proceed until you reconcile the numbers and accept any remaining differences[SD9.1][MG9.2]. Be prepared to consider that the reduced risk from Limb 1 being guaranteed may give owners a legitimate claim to push for a reduction on your usual multiplier.
(2) Map your financial accounts to Limb 1 or Limb 2 using the PAA definitions. Because Limb 1 is not at risk and reconciled each year, wherever there is a judgment call it is worth checking whether they belong in that limb. Misclassified costs can result in underbilling your BAU. These remapped accounts will allow you to recalculate your overhead and profit as the alliance auditors will. Some accounts may need to be prorated according to utilization rates or the number of Billable vs Non-Billable staff. Consider any accounts that might contain mixed entries requiring a split between limbs. A deep understanding of your books is key to achieving true BAU compensation in the alliance; consider appointing one member of your team as an alliance specialist for this purpose.
(3) You will also want to model your compensation at the TOC, and at full painshare where you will likely recover Limb 1 only. Understanding the potential magnitude of losses on a large project will help you to decide if your firm can sustain that level of expected risk before you lock it in.
(4) Review your financial history and think about your future plans, looking for trends that might turn a decent fee today into a mediocre one in five years. Did you have a particularly unprofitable year? Are you investing in technologies that will make your designers more efficient, but that will trade direct labour for overhead? Perhaps you're planning on moving into a larger office when your current lease expires. By spending the time to identify your forward overhead and profit, you can make a case for why fees should not be set mechanically from a historical average and thus avoid the subpar results that might otherwise follow. In the alliance's own terms, a partner earning at its BAU is best-for-project because they aren't worried about making up for poor financials.
(5) Speak with your team about the importance of avoiding phantom time. Every hour worked must be billed; the contract says so, and the target depends on it. If the project scope changes, there is a mechanism for adjusting the TOC, so proper resource planning and management is the best way to stay on budget. An alliance is meant to be transparent, so openly discuss any expected labour issues with the leadership team to find solutions where possible.
Alliance projects are not a trap, even if a poorly priced agreement may feel like one to the unsuspecting. They are honest about costs but require firms to analyze their financials in a way Canadian firms’ books are not set up for. The audit and commercial alignment processes are best viewed as conversations with long-term partners, and best-for-project includes an open discussion of your compensation. An Alliance owner who truly believes this will even push to increase your fees to BAU, something I’ve personally witnessed. Painshare and gainshare only align behaviour if BAU is the baseline.